The Ultimate Mailster Review: Read This Before You Buy

Looking for a newsletter plugin that brings marketing to WordPress? As a serious user, you’re past the basics. 

You’re ready for a system that doesn’t penalize you for growing your list. That’s why Mailster is probably on your radar. 

In this Mailster review, we’ll find out if its powerful integration is worth the setup and potential plugin issues. We cut straight to the point.

TL;DR: Mailster brings your entire email marketing system inside WordPress, giving you full control over unlimited subscribers. The trade-off for this power is data responsibility, which makes using a reliable backup plugin absolutely essential.

Mailster review: A quick overview

This table covers the important points to help you decide quickly:

Email creation & management

The intuitive drag-and-drop editor allows you to quickly build newsletters. However, the true quality of your backend experience depends on having a fast WordPress site.

It feels familiar and works as you would expect. The plugin also includes a library of pre-designed templates. These provide a solid starting point, so you are not starting from scratch.

To save content creators significant time, the plugin includes dynamic tags. These automatically populate your newsletter with your latest WordPress posts, eliminating manual copy-pasting. 

Always check the mobile preview. Over half of your audience will likely read your email on a phone, so this step is not optional. For advanced users, there are even CSS styling options, which are best tested first on a staging site to avoid breaking your live page.

⚖️ Verdict: The editor is powerful and efficient. It successfully mimics the experience of expensive email platforms directly inside WordPress.

Lists and subscribers

Mailster’s approach to subscribers is its biggest selling point. You get unlimited subscriber storage without any tiered pricing. Your cost does not increase as your list grows. This is a fundamental departure from the SaaS model.

⚠️ Note: WordPress security becomes your direct responsibility when self-hosting critical data. Implementing strong security measures is not just a recommendation; it’s a necessity.

The system allows for granular segmentation. This means you can create targeted lists based on user behavior, like who opened a previous email or what they purchased. 

You can easily import existing subscribers with a CSV file after performing a WordPress backup to protect your data. You can also add subscribers from your WordPress user base and use the plugin’s tools to create and customize signup forms for your website.

⚖️ Verdict: This is the core reason to choose Mailster. The freedom from subscriber-based pricing offers immense long-term value and predictability for your budget.

Setting up automation

Mailster provides the essential tools to build automated email sequences. You can create autoresponders that trigger when a user subscribes or send time-based campaigns for events like birthdays. 

But remember, these automations are only effective if they run on time, and that reliability depends on avoiding downtime with solid WordPress hosting.

The workflow to set up new post notifications for your subscribers is especially useful for bloggers. You can also build conditional logic to personalize the user journey. 

⚠️ Warning: It’s tempting to build complex automations from day one. We advise starting with a simple welcome sequence. Master the basics before you add more complexity.

For instance, you can send follow-up emails based on which links a subscriber clicked in a previous campaign. The workflows are also very easy to establish.

⚖️ Verdict: The automation features are more than capable for most businesses. They handle the most critical and common workflows with ease.

Tracking your results

Mailster provides the data needed to understand campaign performance. The dashboard shows you real-time stats for opens, clicks, and unsubscribes. You can see where your subscribers are opening emails with geographical tracking.

🍡 Note: This campaign history is stored in your WordPress database, not an external service. This makes regular backups and maintenance of that database absolutely critical.

More importantly, it has detailed bounce management. This process automatically cleans your list of invalid email addresses. A clean list is absolutely essential for maintaining good deliverability with your sending service. 

You can also integrate with Google Analytics to see how your campaigns contribute to your business goals.

⚖️ Verdict: The analytics are clear and actionable. The bounce management feature is a critical tool for maintaining list health.

Apps and add-ons

The plugin integrates well with the wider WordPress ecosystem. It connects seamlessly with WooCommerce, which is a huge benefit for store owners. It also syncs with popular form builders like Gravity Forms.

The most critical integration is its support for external SMTP providers. You must connect Mailster to a service like Amazon SES or Mailgun to send email reliably. It also supports multilingual sites through plugins like WPML and Polylang.

⚖️ Verdict: The integrations are practical and necessary. Support for professional SMTP services is what makes Mailster a serious marketing tool.

Ease of use

For daily tasks, Mailster is straightforward, provided your site has undergone regular WordPress maintenance. The interface is located inside WordPress, so it feels familiar. Managing your newsletters is much like editing a post.

However, the initial setup requires some technical comfort. Optimizing your server delivery means you will need to configure an external service. This is a one-time task, but it is more involved than simply creating an account on a web-based platform.

⚖️ Verdict: Daily operation is simple. The initial configuration presents a technical hurdle that users must be prepared for.

Getting help

You are not left without support. The plugin includes access to a documentation library that covers setup and common problems. For specific issues, you can submit support tickets as long as you have an active license.

There are also community forums for peer-to-peer advice. A pro tip: search the documentation before submitting a ticket. The answer to your question is often already there.

⚖️ Verdict: The support structure is standard and effective for a premium plugin.

Pricing and plans

Mailster pricing plans are for one site and exclude taxes.

Lifetime usage policy: While billed annually, Mailster offers lifetime usage: 

The ideal user

This plugin excels for a specific user. It is best for:

Competing plugins

If Mailster doesn’t sound quite right for your needs, here are two other popular options:

MailPoet: A strong alternative. It offers a free tier and has its own built-in sending service, which simplifies setup.

The Newsletter Plugin: A simpler, often free option best for very basic newsletter needs. It lacks Mailster’s polish and advanced features.

Parting thoughts

Mailster provides a robust feature set that rivals expensive platforms. It offers exceptional value. This requires using a solid SMTP provider for reliable delivery. This is a clear trade-off. You are trading convenience for significant savings and control.

 It is best suited for those who prioritize budget and ownership. Our final recommendation is simple. Try the official demo before you buy.

FAQs